Limestone terrace beside a refined stone home, with bronze-framed glass doors, a weathered teak bench, and a mature live oak.

Red Crest Is Closed. What Happens Next to the Old BIGS Sign on North Main?

At the June 2 Historic Landmark Commission meeting, the vote on tearing down the building at 305–323 N. Main St. came out 3–3. Six of the seven commissioners were present. City staff announced that the motion had passed. A few days later the city reversed that call. After a review by the city attorney, officials said a tie vote does not count as approval, so the demolition permit was put on hold. The Boerne Star reported that the split vote came right after a commissioner asked about the "antiquated sign out front."

Most people in town know it as the Red Crest Pet Shop sign. City records say it went up as the BIGS of Boerne sign around 1954, decades before Red Crest moved in. It has now outlasted every business that put its name on it, and its next job is the one piece of the redevelopment nobody has settled.

A sign that was built to be relettered

The city staff memo prepared for the commission traces the site's history.

  1. May 1950. Archie and Alice Gerfers open BIGS of Boerne at a different spot on Main Street. The name comes from the first letters of what it sold: Beverages, Ice, Groceries and Sporting Goods.
  2. Circa 1954. The store moves into a new one-story building on North Main, and the freestanding sign goes up out front.
  3. 1978. Alice Gerfers stops running the business, and it changes owners several times. Per the memo, BIGS operated at the site until it closed in the 1980s.
  4. After BIGS. The building is split among several tenants, including Johnny Pfeiffer's feed store, Red Crest Pet Shop and Boerne Grooming. The sign gets Red Crest's name.
  5. About 1999. The Historic District property survey rates the building in fair condition.

The memo describes the building as a one-story vernacular frame structure. It has a stone veneer, a side-gabled roof of corrugated tin, and four additions built onto the back over the years. The city does not consider it a contributing structure to the historic district, even though it is more than 50 years old. About the sign, the memo is more pointed. It says the sign's "distinctive mid-century form is still intact" and calls it one of the few physical connections left to what was once one of Boerne's best-known businesses on North Main.

So the sign has already changed names once and kept its shape. That history helps explain why the latest plans have treated it as something to reuse.

How the plans for the corner kept changing

Park Plaza first went before the commission on March 3, as a discussion item with no vote. The Boerne Star's account of that meeting described a one-story, 12,000-square-foot center. A green courtyard would face Main Street, and parking would move from the front of the lot to the back. An early drawing showed four storefronts: two at 3,000 square feet and two at 2,700. Architect Frank Valadez of SA Partnership Architects told commissioners the goal was to be "stewards of the land along Main Street." He also said he had helped create the Hill Country Mile years earlier with Ron Bowman and Chris Turk.

By June, the plan had changed. The Boerne Star described a two-story, 11,400-square-foot building. The owner is Hill Country Brothers Development LLC, and the project will eventually need City Council approval. In an earlier June story, the paper reported that the old building's asbestos siding would have to be tented and removed before demolition, and Valadez said that work would take time.

The Star also reported that the June 2 vote set off a wave of social media comments opposing demolition, many of them supporting the old building and the nostalgia it carries. At that same meeting, Valadez said the developers planned to let the sign be moved, not demolished.

What Richard Lee offered on July 7

The demolition request came back on July 7, and the sign was at the center of the pitch. In the meeting video, Richard Lee introduced himself as the owner of the property, "which we call the Park Plaza project." He said he and Valadez had spent the previous 30 days reading Facebook comments, talking with city officials and holding in-person conversations around town. Two themes came out of that listening, he said.

"Let's find a way to preserve and create a beneficial reuse of the Red Crest Pet Shop sign, which was the BIGS sign at one time."

The second theme was redesigning the building to fit in with the early-1900s style of the Hill Country Mile. Lee presented both ideas together: "a new concept of an iconic welcome to the Boerne Hill Country Mile sign and a redesigned Park Plaza building." If the city and community backed reusing the sign, he said, he would donate it and pay for part of the refurbishment. That could happen through a public-private partnership with the city or through a crowdfunding campaign, which he said "allows the whole community to get involved."

Valadez then showed mockups of the sign in two color schemes, white and blue, both using the City of Boerne's colors and logos. In one rendering, the sign stood directly across Main Street at the Visit Boerne Center, in front of the visitor parking lot. Valadez said it would still sit on "the same part of Main Street that it exists today." Their goal, he said, was to "keep Boerne's charm and not remove anything."

Commissioner Nichols moved to approve the demolition permit as presented. Commissioner Mains seconded, and the chair announced that the motion passed.

Approved, pending, and undecided

The July 7 vote did not settle the sign. The next agenda item was a certificate of appropriateness for the new building, which is the city's design approval for work in the historic district. City planner Frankie Linder told the commission that request covered the architecture only. Site development, fences and signage would each need their own certificate "later down the road." Staff had also recommended that a design approval for the new building come before any demolition permit is issued.

Here is where things stood heading into November:

  • Red Crest Pet Shop: Closed after 41 years, as The Boerne Life reported in its October 7 newsletter. Boerne Grooming, next door, was expected to move within a couple of weeks.
  • Demolition: Expected "soon" as of that October 7 report, with no date announced.
  • The building: Described in that report as a roughly 12,000-square-foot, courtyard-style center for restaurants and retail, aimed at bringing "higher-end concepts" to that part of Main while keeping the Mile's walkable feel.
  • City Council: The June Boerne Star report said the development will eventually need council approval.
  • The sign: Offered as a donation, shown in mockups across the street, and still waiting on its own separate approval. The commission discussion left the location open, with possible sites still being identified.

The tenant list is just as open. In March, Valadez told the commission the team had been talking with coffee shops and with Mark Bohanan about bringing back Peggy's on the Green, which ended a nine-year run at the Kendall Inn on Nov. 30. "We would like to bring him back and this would be an ideal location," Valadez said, according to the Boerne Star. He also cautioned that any tenant list at that stage was really a wish list. A MySA report on March 26 said Bohanan had not publicly confirmed a return.

The rest of the block, this month

Park Plaza is one of several projects on the north end of the Mile that involve old buildings. A few doors down at 265 N. Main St., Hill & Bach Cellars is moving into the Jacob Luckenbach House. The Boerne Life reports the house was built by Rudolph Carstanjen and bought by Jacob Luckenbach in 1883. It later served as a home, a cosmetics studio and a dress shop, and it still has its original cedar ceiling beams and a log-cabin core. The wine venue's September newsletter was counting down to an October grand opening.

The Visit Boerne Center, where the sign could land, sits almost directly across from the Park Plaza site, according to the Boerne Star. That puts both sides of the street on the walking route for the November events on the 1.1-mile Hill Country Mile. Here's the city's lineup:

  • Fall Diva Night, Thursday, Nov. 5: An evening of shopping at downtown boutiques.
  • Pink Friday, Nov. 20: 30 local businesses are taking part, including a Pink Friday Duck Hunt where shoppers look for hidden pink ducks to earn prize entries.
  • Dickens on Main, Nov. 27–28: Thanksgiving weekend on the Mile, lining up with Plaid Friday and Small Business Saturday.

On any of those evenings, the old BIGS sign is still worth a look on your way up North Main. Its Red Crest lettering may be the last name it carries in its current spot. Where it goes next will be decided at a separate signage approval that hasn't happened yet.

If you own a home near the Hill Country Mile, every new plan on North Main changes what's around you. Harkin Realty follows these projects block by block, so we can tell you how changes on your street may affect your home's value. Start with an instant home valuation, and we'll add the local detail.

Work With Us

Bringing together a team with the passion, dedication, and resources to help our clients reach their buying and selling goals. With you every step of the way. Contact us today!

Follow Me on Instagram